Old-Fashioned, Yet Timeless and Chewy Caramels

If you want to learn how to make old-fashioned caramels through the caramelization method and not milk caramels, look no further.  We finally conquered our fear of caramel by making sauce a few days ago.  It was a bit scary, but we did it!

Once that was over and I survived the molten mess, I decided to go a step further and try out caramels!  I decided to pick and chose from a variety of people, but based the cooking method off of this one in particular. Of course, I decided to reduce the sugar and fat as normal.

how to make caramels

I was so thrilled!  No crystallizing, a lovely color was forming and things were trucking along.

how to make caramels

Boy, it really bubbles up when you add the milk like they tell you.  It happens very fast!

how to make caramels

So following the recipe, I turn it off and pour the mixture in the pan.  Check.

how to make caramels

And I waited.

how to make caramels

Waited some more.  What happened?!?

how to make caramels

It never firmed up. It was a nice sauce, though.

how to make caramels

Apparently this is way too soft.  It was gloppy and not thin enough for sauce and too thin for caramels.  A quick search online said 240F (116C) is a super soft caramel.  So I put it back on the heat and heated caramel up to 245F (118C.)  And back into the pan.

And I waited.  It’s caramel! 

how to make caramels

And boy is it hard to learn how to cut caramel.  It’s slippery, sticky and scary.

how to make caramels

But once you get the hang of it, it’s not too bad.

how to make caramels

The texture is still quite soft and wants to flatten out a bit.  It’s also very stretchy and melting quickly.

Next time, we shall push the temperature to 248F (120C.)  But that is for another day.  And with a different recipe.  If you want to try your own, below is the recipe I followed on how to make old-fashioned caramels.

how to make caramels

Old-Fashioned Caramels

Old fashioned caramels take time but the taste is outstanding.
Print Recipe
Prep Time15 minutes
Cook Time45 minutes
Servings64 pieces
Calories 27.8

Ingredients

  • 1 cup (200g) granulated sugar
  • ¾ cup (180mL) heavy whipping cream
  • ¼ cup (60mL) water
  • 2 tbs (28g) butter
  • ½ tsp (2.5g) salt

Instructions

  • Prepare an 8×8 heatproof pan (20cm) by lining with aluminum foil and spray with pam or grease with butter. Set aside.
  • Pour water and sugar into a heavy based, 3 quart sauce pan.
  • Do not stir! Let the mixture simmer at medium low heat until all the sugar is absorbed (it will look clear and not grainy.) Turn heat to medium high.
  • The water will begin to boil rapidly and then slow. This means the water is nearly all boiled off and this is where you watch carefully. Bring the mixture up to a golden amber color or 325F (163C.)
  • Turn off heat and immediately add in the butter slowly stirring constantly with a heatproof spoon. It will bubble up and produces a lot of steam so do so cautiously. Slowly add in the cream, return heat to medium. Using a heat tolerant spoon, stir constantly until you reach 248F (120C.)
  • Carefully pour mixture into the greased pan and let cool completely, approximately 1 -2 hours before cutting. Wrap in wax paper and store in an airtight container.

Notes

  • Shortcut method: 
    To speed up the cooking process and cut the time in half,  make the following changes to the above ingredients: Replace cream with 1 can (14oz) sweetened condensed milk
    Reduce brown sugar to 1 1/2 cups (339g)
    Reduce corn-syrup to 1/2 cup (120mL)
  • Non-stick pans are notorious for causing sugar to crystalize when making candy.  A good stainless steel pan with a heavy bottom is ideal.
  • If you don’t have a thermometer, you can test it by dropping a small amount in cold water.  Wait several moments to allow syrup to cool before handling.  A ball should form and easily flattened when removed and pressed with your fingers.  
  • Caramel is very hot.  Never leave the pan unattended and take extreme care when working with heating sugar. 
  • Make them butterscotch!  Replace the white sugar with brown sugar in equal amounts.
  • Adjust the heat as necessary.  Do not allow the mixture to boil over, especially on glass stovetops.  Hot sugar syrup and milk products can damage glass surfaces.  Electric glass stovetops are not recommended for making candies.
  • Do not touch or taste hot caramel.  Use oven mitts and let the caramel cool completely before handling or consuming.  You will be burned if you fail to heed this advice. 

Nutrition Facts
Old-Fashioned Caramels
Serving Size
 
1 piece
Amount per Serving
Calories
27.8
% Daily Value*
Fat
 
1.3
g
2
%
Saturated Fat
 
0.9
g
6
%
Sodium
 
1.9
mg
0
%
Carbohydrates
 
4.2
g
1
%
* Percent Daily Values are based on a 2000 calorie diet.
* Calories provided as a courtesy and not guaranteed.

You May Also Like:

How to Make Clarified Butter

Today we will learn how to make clarified butter. In the last few weeks, we learned how to melt butter on the stovetop which was an easy process to do. By taking a little more time, we can clarify butter! What is the purpose of clarified butter? Glad you asked! When...

Copycat Keebler Pecan Sandies Recipe

A friend of ours loves Keebler Pecan Sandies. After about 200 or so cookies and making a fabulous pecan sugar cookie, the elves would be proud of this copycat recipe. Or maybe a little jealous? Many different types of cookies were baked along the way in an attempt to...

Toasted Coconut Sandies Recipe

A Little Background on Coconut Sandies Learn how to make this coconut sandies recipe in a few easy steps. You can choose a few ways to prepare the cookies. By shaping and chilling them, you will have a thin, buttery cookie filled with coconut in every bite. Rolling...

More Ways to Connect!

Do you want to share your results?  Do you have more questions on this recipe?  Did you find an error?  We want to help and we appreciate yours.  Please contact us.  We love hearing from you!

Follow Us:

Questions? We're Here to Help!

Do you have questions about our recipes, want to brag about your accomplishments, complain, compliment, send stories of your furry pets, or found an error in our typing?  We want to hear from you!  Please contact us and we will get back to you as soon as we finish baking our latest creation.  Or sleeping.

Comments:

0 Comments
5 from 1 vote (1 rating without comment)
Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




Pin It on Pinterest