The Dickens’ Type Tale of Two Thermometers

Sit back and relax while I tell you the tale of the two thermometers.  I tried a new recipe and a new thermometer at the same time.   See how this is already shaping up?

The cheap Acu-rite thermometer from Walmart works great, but my eyes don’t.  Since it wasn’t as detailed as I’d like, I bought a Taylor brand.  I was having trouble reading the glass thermometer and I liked that the new one had a well spaced candy making gauge.

Tale of Two Thermometers

So we began making some caramel. At first, it wasn’t far off.  About 2 degrees.  Around 100°F (38°C,) Taylor started to show a 7 degree discrepancy.  The metal thermometer started to slow down and seemed to get stuck at this temperature for the longest time. 

Tale of Two Thermometers

I was so busy watching the thermometers that I burnt my candy sauce!  I didn’t realize it until the rancid smell wafted up to my nose. 

Since it was already scorched, I decided to try the water drop method to see which thermometer was correct.  At softball on the Acu-rite and not even showing boiling on the Taylor (notice the boiling of the syrup,) I dropped a bit into cold water.  It formed a little ball that fell apart when you moved it around.  Looks like the cheap thermometer is winning.

I didn’t get any further pictures of inaccuracy as the candy syrup began to smoke and I needed to stop immediately before it became dangerous.  But I have a picture of the candy hardened.  Doesn’t it look tasty?  I hate wasting food!  It’s very upsetting.  

I did some research and read it could be the immersion line wasn’t deep enough.  So while I was boiling away the hard, burnt candy, I stuck in the thermometer.  As the water just started boiling, the temperature stuck at 180F.  I added more water to be sure.  At a rapid boil for 10 minutes, it still never reached above 200F.   

I  may have a lemon but I’m not willing to find out with another one at this large of a temperature discrepancy.  I decided to finish cleaning off the thermometer, let it cool and carefully placed it back in the packaging.  Glad I kept that receipt!  I’m going back to my $3 thermometer.  Maybe I’ll buy a backup…  

And this is also why I was searching for a new thermometer in case you were wondering.  It was inevitable that I would drop this poor fellow.  Sorry about that, Thermador. We made some great peanut butter fudge together and you will be fondly my friend. Yes, I name a lot of things in my kitchen and talk to inanimate objects. You will live on in this tale of the two thermometers.

You May Also Like:

Extraordinary Chocolate Spice Cake Recipe

This extraordinary chocolate spice cake recipe will make you the talk of the town. With just a few spices and you'll have an amazing chocolate cake to kick off the fall weather and start the holiday season. The key to this recipe is steeping the cocoa and spices in...

Millionaire’s Shortbread, Eat Like your Rich

What is a Millionaires Shortbread? Millionaire's Shortbread is a melt-in-your-mouth shortbread cookie, topped with delicious soft salted caramel and followed by a layer of rich dark chocolate. If you enjoy Twix candy bars, this recipe will be your new best friend....

Razzmatazz Raspberry Buttercream Frosting

Razzmatazz raspberry buttercream frosting is a mouthful both figuratively and literally. And it is so incredibly fun to say aloud. Try it. I'll wait patiently. Didn't I tell you? It's just as pleasurable to eat as it is to say so let's get started. Tart and sweet just...

More Ways to Connect!

Do you want to share your results?  Do you have more questions on this recipe?  Did you find an error?  We want to help and we appreciate yours.  Please contact us.  We love hearing from you!

Follow Us:

Comments:

0 Comments
Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Pin It on Pinterest